Reddit (RDDT) Stock Plunges 41% YTD Despite Strong Q4 Earnings as Analyst Targets Drop

Key Takeaways

• Bank of America lowered Reddit’s price target from $205 to $175 while maintaining a “neutral” stance
• Shares have plummeted 41% year-to-date, currently trading near $136, far below the 12-month peak
• Fourth-quarter revenue reached $725.6M, representing 70% year-over-year growth and surpassing forecasts by 9%
• Co-founder and CEO Steve Huffman offloaded approximately $2.39M worth of shares on March 31 via planned trading arrangement
• UK’s Information Commissioner’s Office levied a £14.47M penalty against Reddit for inadequate protection of minors’ data

Reddit delivered impressive fourth-quarter financial results on the surface. The company reported revenue of $725.6 million, marking a 70% surge compared to the prior-year period and exceeding Wall Street projections by 9%. Adjusted EBITDA soared 112% year-over-year to $327 million. Earnings per share of $1.24 significantly outperformed the consensus estimate of $0.96.

Reddit, Inc., RDDT

Yet the market reaction paints a contrasting picture.

RDDT shares have cratered 41% since the beginning of the year, hovering around the $136 mark. This represents a steep decline from the stock’s 12-month peak of $282.95. Bank of America revised its price objective downward from $205 to $175 this past Thursday, adopting a neutral perspective — though notably, even this reduced target suggests approximately 28% potential upside from present trading levels.

Bank of America’s cautious stance isn’t an isolated case. Goldman Sachs previously adjusted its target from $236 down to $206 in February, also assigning a neutral rating. Both Roth MKM and Robert W. Baird maintain neutral-to-hold recommendations on the stock.

However, not all analysts share this pessimistic view. Evercore continues to back an outperform rating with a $290 price objective. Truist Securities increased its target to $275 following the Q4 report, characterizing it as a “Classic Beat & Raise” performance. Citizens maintained its market outperform designation and $300 target, highlighting the impressive 75% year-over-year surge in advertising revenue during Q4.

The analyst consensus currently registers as a “Moderate Buy” with an average price target of $240.85 — representing nearly a 100% premium to current trading levels.

Insider Transactions Show Mixed Signals

Insider trading activity has presented conflicting indicators. CEO Steve Huffman divested 14,697 shares on March 31, generating approximately $2.39 million through transactions executed at prices ranging from $126.40 to $134.84. This sale occurred under a pre-established Rule 10b5-1 trading arrangement initiated in May 2025. Huffman continues to maintain ownership of more than 490,000 shares through various trust structures.

Earlier in the year, Huffman also liquidated 18,000 shares during January at $232.78 per share, collecting roughly $4.19 million in proceeds.

Conversely, Director Sarah Farrell demonstrated confidence by purchasing 43,800 shares in February at $149.52 per share — representing a $6.5 million commitment to the company’s prospects.

Throughout the most recent quarter, company insiders collectively disposed of $61.25 million in stock while acquiring $8.87 million. Insiders maintain aggregate ownership of 34.25% of the enterprise.

British Regulators Issue £14.47M Penalty

Reddit is also grappling with regulatory challenges across the Atlantic. The UK’s Information Commissioner’s Office imposed a £14.47 million fine on the platform for insufficient safeguards surrounding children’s personal information. Authorities determined that Reddit’s age verification protocols fell short of required standards.

The company unveiled a $1 billion share repurchase program concurrent with its Q4 earnings release — a strategic decision that demonstrates management’s conviction despite the stock’s recent downturn.

Citizens highlighted one particular concern meriting attention: U.S. platform engagement time decreased 10.5% year-over-year in January, even as advertising revenue maintained upward momentum.

Reddit’s 50-day moving average currently stands at $150.24, while the 200-day average sits at $195.96. The equity carries a beta coefficient of 2.39, indicating significant volatility relative to broader market movements — amplifying both gains and losses.

The post Reddit (RDDT) Stock Plunges 41% YTD Despite Strong Q4 Earnings as Analyst Targets Drop appeared first on Blockonomi.