Papa John’s (PZZA) Stock Jumps 19% Following $1.5B Buyout Proposal

TLDR

• Irth Capital Management has put forward a proposal to acquire Papa John’s for $47 per share in a privatization deal
• The proposal places Papa John’s valuation at approximately $1.5 billion, representing a 50% premium over pre-announcement prices
• The bid receives financial backing from Brookfield Asset Management
• PZZA shares jumped approximately 19% on Wednesday, finishing at $38.86 following The Wall Street Journal’s report
• Papa John’s has been the subject of three acquisition-related rumors over the past six months; a prior Irth/Apollo transaction collapsed in 2024

Shares of Papa John’s experienced a significant rally of nearly 19% on Wednesday following the revelation that a Qatari-supported investment firm had presented a formal acquisition proposal to privatize the pizza restaurant company.

Papa John’s International, Inc., PZZA

According to The Wall Street Journal’s initial report, Irth Capital Management, with backing from Brookfield Asset Management, has tabled an offer of $47 per share for Papa John’s International. This proposal establishes a company valuation of approximately $1.5 billion.

The proposed acquisition price represents roughly a 50% premium compared to PZZA’s trading level before the bid became public knowledge. Papa John’s market capitalization stood at approximately $1 billion prior to Wednesday’s trading session.

PZZA trading experienced a temporary suspension during Wednesday’s session after a circuit breaker was activated due to the sharp price increase following the announcement. The stock concluded trading at $38.86.

Papa John’s management is presently evaluating the acquisition proposal. The company has provided no assurance that it will accept the current offer, leaving open the possibility for competing bids from other potential acquirers.

This marks Irth’s second attempt to purchase Papa John’s. The investment fund previously pursued an acquisition of the pizza chain in 2024 in partnership with Apollo Global Management, though negotiations ultimately collapsed without reaching an agreement.

Irth already holds a position in Papa John’s and has recently expanded its effective ownership to approximately 10%. Founded in 2024, the fund operates with financial support from Sheikh Mohamed bin Abdulla Al-Thani, a Qatari royal family member and former Qatar Investment Authority executive.

Co-founder Matthew Bradshaw brings experience from his previous leadership role at Durational Capital Management. The investment team also features Mack Abbot, who previously worked at Starboard Value — the activist investment firm that once maintained a Papa John’s stake.

A Chain Under Pressure

Completing a Papa John’s acquisition would represent one of Irth’s inaugural major transactions. For Papa John’s, the timing coincides with a challenging operational period.

Last month, the pizza chain announced plans to shutter hundreds of U.S. locations, streamline its menu offerings, and implement corporate workforce reductions as components of a comprehensive turnaround strategy. North American comparable store sales are projected to decline this year.

PZZA shares have declined approximately 55% in value during the previous five-year period. The stock reached its peak above $140 in 2021 and has experienced continuous downward pressure subsequently.

Papa John’s has navigated multiple years of operational difficulties, partially attributed to public controversies involving founder John Schnatter. He departed from the CEO position in 2017 after making several controversial public remarks, and subsequently resigned from his board chairman role. The company experienced notable sales declines in the controversy’s wake.

Analyst View

Currently, eight Wall Street analysts provide coverage for PZZA, establishing a consensus Moderate Buy rating. This consensus comprises three Buy ratings and five Hold ratings issued during the most recent three-month period.

The consensus price target stands at $42.57, suggesting approximately 10% potential upside from Wednesday’s closing price — not factoring in the $47 per share proposal from Irth.

Papa John’s stock concluded Wednesday’s session at $38.86, remaining notably beneath the $47 per share that Irth has proposed.

The post Papa John’s (PZZA) Stock Jumps 19% Following $1.5B Buyout Proposal appeared first on Blockonomi.